[jmsmartins]

CLOSED
Guys, sorry to say i just sold my i900, and therefore i close this thread. Feel free to keep posting your opinions but i will not update rankings.
It was very nice to meet so talented guys here, and chating with really nice peolpe. I will visit this section from time to time, to see how the GREAT OMNIA goes
in the meanwhile, i'm just next door in i8000 section.
It would be awesome if this amazing chefs and rom testers could buy an i8000 so we could all continue this "project".
Will miss this!

Cya all

Wellcome to "ROM's Rating/Ranking"

Hi everyone!
I would like to start this topic, in wich i hope all users post their opinion about the roms they try.
I will try as much as i can to make an updated Ranking/Rating based in YOUR opinion.
Please indicate the Rom's AUTOR and WM version. And of course a 1-10 rating (pleas use whole numbers only) and a short (or not so short) list of the reasons why you give that rate.
It would be nice if you tell us also the bugs you found and some apps you use without issues (including your UI). Include suggestions if you want.
FEEL FREE TO POST SCREENSHOTS (would be nice indeed )

Here are some suggestions of features you can have in mind when rating:

STABILITY
SPEED
RESPONSIVENESS
FREE PROGRAM MEMORY
COOKED APPS
DESIGN
ISSUES (major/minor)
I want to thank in advance to all that will post here, and please, if you think this topic has no purppose...let me know that. every suggestion is wellcome

I think it's a good way to show to the chefs around some gratitude for their amazing job and makes easier for users to choose/debate roms

ATENTION: THESE RANKINGS ARE NOT MINE, I MAKE SOME REVIEWS AND RATINGS BUT THE FINAL TABLE IS THE RESULT OF ALL OUR RATINGS

This post has been edited by jmsmartins: 08 June 2010 - 01:15 PM

[Sponsored Links]

[jmsmartins]

6.5 ROMs

Download Links and flashing info (thanks Sb.) HERE

1st - Ryrzy 28002 m2d ----- 10/10 (3 comment)

2nd

- Shokka9 23009 (shk17) m2d ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- P_Dhee 28008 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- P_Dhee 21885 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- Sector 23009 m2d ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- P_Dhee 28205 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- Nicklas 23620 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- P_Dhee 21888 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- Ock 21889 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)


3rd

- P_Dhee 23618 Lite ----- 10/10 (2 comment)

- P_Dhee 28889 Lite ----- 10/10 (2 comment)



4th - P_Dhee 28011 Lite ----- 10/10 (3 comment)

5th - Cruddasj 28014 m2d (black beauty) ----- 10/10 (2 comment)

6th - P_Dhee 28014 Lite ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

7th

- P_Dhee 28002 Lite/m2d ----- 10/10 (2 comment)

- Nicklas 28014 Lite ----- 10/10 (2 comment)


8th - P_Dhee 23620 m2d ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

9th - Cruddasj 28014 Lite (true and blue) ----- 10/10 (3 comment)

10th - Steff195 28025 Lite/m2d ----- 10/10 (3 comment)

11th - Ryrzy 28002 Lite ----- 10/10 (2 comment)

12th

- Shokka9 23064 m2d (shk23) ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- Cruddasj 23515 Lite (true and blue) ----- 10/10 (1 comment)

- Nicklas 23620 Flotanium ----- 10/10 (1 comment)


13th - Nicklas 28005 Classic/Neo ----- 10/10 (4 comment)

14th

- Ock 23093 m2d ----- 9/10 (1 comment)

- Cruddasj 28205 m2d ----- 9/10 (1 comment)


15th

- Nicklas 28005 Flotanium ----- 9/10 (1 comment)

- Bruno Adler 28014 ----- 9/10 (1 comment)


16th - Mr Hammer 23515 Lite ----- 9/10 (1 comment)

17th - KC hybrid 23016/21928 m2d/Lite ----- 9/10 (2 comment)

18th - KC 23081 Lite ----- 9/10 (4 comment)

19th - P_Dhee 23614 Lite ----- 9/10 (1 comment)

20th

- Ryrzy 23506 m2d ----- 9/10 (1 comment)

- Ryrzy 23616 m2d ----- 9/10 (1 comment)


21st

- P_Dhee 28005 Lite ----- 9/10 (2 comment)

- Anzo 23088 m2d ----- 9/10 (2 comment)


22nd - Shokka9 23017 Lite (shk22L) ----- 8/10 (1 comment)

23rd - Stev 23081 PLite ----- 8/10 (3 comment)

24th - Ryrzy 23081 m2d ----- 8/10 (2 comment)

25th - Sector 23504 classic ----- 8/10 (1 comment)

26th - Sector 23064 Neo ----- 8/10 (1 comment)

27th - Nicklas 23504 Flotanium ----- 7/10 (4 comment)

28th - Nicklas 23506 Flotanium ----- 7/10 (3 comment)

29th - Nicklas - 23506 FlotaniumLite ----- 6/10 (2 comment)

This post has been edited by jmsmartins: 21 January 2010 - 02:06 PM

[jmsmartins]

6.1 ROMS

1st - Ryrzy 21054 lite ----- 10/10 (1comment)

2nd - KC's Lite 21001 (from omnia II) ----- 9/10 (3comment)

3rd - Shokka9 20270 LITE ----- 9/10 (4comment)

4th - Qbus 20270 m2d (QB07M) ----- 9/10 (1comment)

5th - Qbus 20270 lite (QB06) ----- 8/10 (1comment)

6th - SAMSUNG 20270 DXIA5pda/DXIA2phone normal ----- 8/10 (1comment)

This post has been edited by jmsmartins: 21 January 2010 - 01:48 PM

[jmsmartins]

I give KC's m2d UL hybrid a 9
reasons: great speed and responsivness, plenty of free program memory (~60Mb with titanium/~50 with manila). every app i installed worked great! i don't give it a 10 because it's the old GUI (although i DON'T CARE), manila original theme is UGLY and we have to install almost everything (but wtf, it's a UL rom...).

stability10
speed 10
responsivness 9
free prog memory 9
coooked apps 7
design 7
NO ISSUES till now

Currently using this

screenshots later

This post has been edited by jmsmartins: 04 November 2009 - 07:25 PM

[Lunchbox77]

and design

[jmsmartins]

Lunchbox77, on Nov 4 2009, 14:42, said:

and design

thanks bro, i totally forgot that!

[Lunchbox77]

Stev's personal 23081 PLite

STABILITY 9 (no issues yet)
SPEED 7 (sometimes a bit slow)
RESPONSIVENESS 8
FREE PROGRAM MEMORY 9 (with Olite apps installes till a useful ROM over 100M-s
COOKED APPS 9 (need more omnialite )
DESIGN 9 (nice wallpaper and skin choice)

[jmsmartins]

Lunchbox77, on Nov 4 2009, 15:58, said:

Stev's personal 23081 PLite

STABILITY 9 (no issues yet)
SPEED 7 (sometimes a bit slow)
RESPONSIVENESS 8
FREE PROGRAM MEMORY 9 (with Olite apps installes till a useful ROM over 100M-s
COOKED APPS 9 (need more omnialite )
DESIGN 9 (nice wallpaper and skin choice)

Great post, that's exactly what i talked about
thank u

btw, that rom crashes in my phone after soft reset

[jmsmartins]

SHK 22L 23017

stability 9
speed 9
responsivness 8
free program memory 7
cooked apps 8
design 9

needs omnialite apps but it's one of my favorites though

[KazzarEB]

DXID1 23064 TitaniumNeo Hades from Sector (Discussion Topic)

stability 9
speed 8
responsivness 7
free program memory 7
cooked apps 8
design 9

Waiting to try the new 23504 released today...

This post has been edited by KazzarEB: 04 November 2009 - 06:42 PM

[jmsmartins]

stev LiteP 23081

stability 5 ---> 8
speed 8
responsivness 8
free program memory 8
cooked apps 9
design 9

ISSUE: it crashes whenever (or almost) i SR and i can't solve it by any means, even with HR. thats too bad for me

EDIT: it seems to be a problem with the keyboard! if we install the omnialite keyb by cab it will fix this issue! at least it fixes it for me

This post has been edited by jmsmartins: 30 November 2009 - 02:41 PM

[leap_ahead]

stability 9
speed 9
responsivness 9
free program memory 10
cooked apps 8
design 6

the best for me !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This post has been edited by leap_ahead: 04 November 2009 - 09:20 PM

[Lunchbox77]

jmsmartins, on Nov 4 2009, 18:12, said:

Great post, that's exactly what i talked about
thank u

btw, that rom crashes in my phone after soft reset

i don't have that issue works like a charm, u hve the latest version? he updated it few times

[jmsmartins]

leap_ahead, on Nov 4 2009, 20:00, said:

stability 9
speed 9
responsivness 9
free program memory 10
cooked apps 10
design 9

the best for me !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

manila isn't cooked in in that rom. would you give 9 to design without it?
why do you give cooked apps a 10?

i'm not criticising, i just want to understand better the rate u gave.

thanks for your feedback!!! will update asap

[Lunchbox77]

i think speed is very rom dependent, so it's not a huge score 1 sec here or there

maybe we can judge the custom boot screen

for that i give a 10 for steV

This post has been edited by Lunchbox77: 04 November 2009 - 08:19 PM

[jmsmartins]

Lunchbox77, on Nov 4 2009, 20:12, said:

i think speed is very rom dependent, so it's not a huge score 1 sec here or there

maybe we can judge the custom boot screen

for that i give a 10 for steV

i think we can include it in design but it's OK to rate it separetelly
about your 1st question, i downloaded it yesterday morning or the after in the evening, i can't remember.. isn't that the last one?

[leap_ahead]

jmsmartins, on Nov 4 2009, 22:10, said:

manila isn't cooked in in that rom. would you give 9 to design without it?
why do you give cooked apps a 10?

i'm not criticising, i just want to understand better the rate u gave.

thanks for your feedback!!! will update asap

ops sorry ...this rate after setup some apps from me

some screenshot here

http://www.modaco.com/content-page/285664/...2009/page/6380/

This post has been edited by leap_ahead: 04 November 2009 - 08:56 PM

[Lunchbox77]

leap_ahead, on Nov 4 2009, 22:53, said:

ops sorry ...this rate after setup some apps from me

some screenshot here

http://www.modaco.com/content-page/285664/...2009/page/6380/

looks nice, but don't like the taskbar, i give for the design 7

[leap_ahead]

UltraLite ROM with some useful : like this program nodata,srs wow,favorite hacking, Windows Media Player,media album. is most importand for me

This post has been edited by leap_ahead: 04 November 2009 - 09:06 PM

[jmsmartins]

Screenshots for KC's UL Hybrid

Attached File(s)

•  ScreenShot1.Png (10.05K)
  Number of downloads: 196
•  ScreenShot2.Png (66.4K)
  Number of downloads: 215
•  ScreenShot3.Png (13.15K)
  Number of downloads: 141
•  ScreenShot4.Png (8.04K)
  Number of downloads: 145

[Sponsored Links]